Levels of faith and pain intensity
Research studies show significant relationships between strong spiritual well-being, increased pain tolerance and an ability to cope with pain.
A recent study demonstrated that spirituality well-being, and faith particularly, as measured by the Functional Assessment of Chronic Illness Therapy – Spiritual Well-Being-Extended scale (FACIT-Sp-Ex), was significantly related to reduced pain intensity in some study participants over a course of pain treatment. What accounts for this relationship? The authors speculated that:
“It may be that a strong element of “faith” is associated with a greater confidence or trust in health professionals and a greater likelihood of following their advice. It is also possible that those with higher levels of “faith” are more likely to improve because they are more likely to engage with a program that seeks to incorporate a spiritual and existential component. It is also possible that they are more eager to please the program providers and report better outcomes. All of these possibilities would need to be explored further and cannot be answered in the present study.”
The quotation suggests that higher levels of faith might be associated with reduced pain intensity in some people with pain.
Forms of faith and pain intensity: a hypothesis
A hypothesis is that, in addition to levels of faith, particular forms of faith, or combinations of faith forms, could reduce pain intensity.
So, what forms of faith are there? The following forms are commonly distinguished in philosophy of religion (Table 1).
|Faith form||Name in philosophy of religion|
|A feeling of existential confidence||the ‘purely affective’ model|
|Knowledge of specific truths, revealed by God||the ‘special knowledge’ model|
|Belief that God exists||the ‘belief’ model|
|Believing in (‘trusting in’) God||the ‘trust’ model|
|Practical commitment beyond the evidence to one’s belief that God exists||the ‘doxastic venture’ model|
|Hoping the God who saves exists||the ‘hope’ model|
Scientific study could investigate if some forms of faith are significantly related to reduced pain intensity compared to other forms, or combinations of forms, of faith. These same forms of faith could be used prognostically by clinicians to predict improvements in pain intensity in some patients, or in other outcomes, such as quality of life or pain-related disability. Qualitative research could investigate if patient conceptions of faith accurately map onto faith forms, as identified by philosophers.
Faith beyond religion
Can faith exist without commitment to any religion? Tennant wrote that: ‘faith is an outcome of the inborn propensity to self-conservation and self-betterment which is a part of human nature, and is no more a miraculously superadded endowment than is sensation or understanding.’ He thinks that ‘much of the belief which underlies knowledge is the outcome of faith which ventures beyond the apprehension and treatment of data to supposition, imagination and creation of ideal objects, and justifies its audacity and irrationality (in accounting them to be also real) by practical actualization.’
If faith exists beyond religion, then people who commit themselves to a view based on a particular interpretation of reality exclusive of the objective verification of the truth, are people of faith. Faith of this kind may be religious without being theistic, as in Buddhism or Taoism. Or, it may be scientific when people propose that reality is no more than what is discoverable by the natural sciences (e.g. ‘scientific atheists’, ‘naturalists’).
Study of the interaction between faith and pain could investigate relationships between forms of faith and pain intensity, in addition to other psychosocial outcomes. Such forms span broadly across traditional orthodox religious thesim, relgious non-theism, scientific atheism or naturalism. Interaction between forms and levels of faith, and pain outcomes, is a further possibility. Personal faith could be a useful tool in the clinical armamentarium.
 Lysne CJ, Wachholtz AB. Pain, spirituality, and meaning making: What can we learn from the literature? Religions 2010;2(1):1.
 Keefe FJ, Affleck G, Lefebvre J, Underwood L, Caldwell DS, Drew J, et al. Living with rheumatoid arthritis: The role of daily spirituality and daily religious and spiritual coping. J Pain 2001;2(2):101-10.
 McCabe R, Murray R, Austin P, Siddall P. Spiritual and existential factors predict pain relief in a pain management program with a meaning-based component. J Pain Manage 2018:11(2):163-170.
 Bishop J. Faith. In: Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy. Available at: https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/faith/
 Tennant FR. 1943/1989. Faith [Tennant, 1943, Chapter 6]. In T. Penelhum (ed.), Faith, London: Collier Macmillan, 99-112.
Can you distinguish between faith and belief?
I am currently drafting a paper along similar lines.
Thanks for your question. Let’s compare faith as belief with faith as trust to highlight similarities and differences. Hopefully, this helps!
Many philosophers of religion think that theistic faith is faith in God. Thus, it is thought that theistic faith must take an ‘intentional object,’ which represents what faith is about. For example, some philosophers think the object of faith is belief in a certain theological proposition or statement; others view the object of faith not as a proposition about God, but trust in God himself.
On one view of faith, faith is belief that a proposition or set of propositions is true. Propositions of faith have specific meaning or ‘content’; namely, that God exists, He is good, He has a plan of salvation, and so on, which are adhered to with personal conviction. Conviction in the truth of a scientific proposition is not theistic faith since it lacks the appropriate meaning. Thus, the meaning of the faith-proposition is what counts as faith.
Still, believing in faith-propositions as revealed by God ultimately rests on believing in God. On this form of faith, faith is believing in God, not believing that God exists. To believe in God involves trusting in Him, and this requires ongoing personal commitment. The ‘trust’ form of faith emphasises action rather than cognition.
Happy to discuss!